The Former Dockworkers Registered Pension Fund completed a full buyout at the end of 2019. James Phillips at Professional Pensions has considered some of the challenges and pitfalls that the trustee (including Ian Forrest, director of Trustee Corporation Limited) encountered along the way. This included discovering a GMP record with HMRC for the spouse of a female member when, so far as the trustee was aware, the fund had only ever had male members. Below is an extract from the full article.
Going to Market
Now, it was time to go to market. LCP, as the scheme’s adviser, approached four insurers. The response for quotes surprised the trustees, however – the scheme could afford buyout two or three years earlier than it had anticipated.
Forrest says it was “serendipity”; the combination of funding and a de-risked investment portfolio meant the scheme could not only afford buyout, but would have money left over after doing so.
[Duncan] Buchanan [of Hogan Lovells, legal advisers to the trustee] says: “I remember one of the trade union trustees – who’d been around at the time of the L&G buy-in – saying this is just a no-brainer now. If we don’t transact now, and the market goes away from us, think what people are going to think: You had the opportunity to secure everybody in full and you didn’t take it. This time, the trustees were fully behind it.”
There was a “pot of gold”, says [Julia] Tyrrell [Pi Consulting co-founder and director, who acted as fund secretary], and that needed to be kept as intact as possible.
The scheme would have to move quickly to beat the markets. Forrest notes the size of the scheme meant a “small movement in the markets went a long way”. At the same time, the demographics of the scheme were helping. By the time of the eventual wind-up, the scheme had only 110 deferred members and around 9,000 pensioners.
Vivien Cockerill has joined as a director of The Trustee Corporation Limited. Glyn Ryland will also join as a director in June 2020
Glyn was head of the UK Pensions Team at Gowling WLG for 20 years, where he advised a range of pension plan and employer clients in both the UK and internationally, with plan sizes ranging from billions of pounds to smaller or executive pension plans. Glyn was a founding member of the Association of Pensions Lawyers’ Investment Sub-Committee and he is a trustee of specialist think tank the International Longevity Centre UK. He is recognised as an Eminent Practitioner by Chambers and Partners and is in The Legal 500’s ‘Hall of Fame.’
Vivien is an experienced pensions lawyer and professional trustee with wide experience gained from more than 30 years in the pensions industry. She currently chairs the £1.3 billion Schroders Retirement Benefits Scheme and the staff pension plans of the Wellcome Trust, where she also sits on the defined contribution governance group.
Matthew Giles, a co-director, said: “We would like to welcome Glyn and Vivien to the firm. Their considerable experience as lawyers and as trustees makes them fantastic additions to our trusteeship business.”
The Trustee Corporation chairs the Board of the Trustee of The Former Registered Dock Workers Pension Fund, which was set up to provide pensions and benefits for dockworkers and former dockworkers at various UK ports and shipping organisations. We are pleased to report that the fund undertook a full risk reduction project in November 2017. This resulted in all of the fund’s liabilities being bought in with Pension Insurance Corporation (PIC) and represented the biggest buy-in of 2017. Ian Forrest said: “We are delighted to have secured the benefits for all members in full with an established, UK regulated insurance company. The Trustees are grateful to their various advisers for preparing the fund to achieve this buy-in, and to PIC for dealing with the transaction so efficiently.” A copy of the full press release is available.
2016 saw Trustee Corporation proudly reach its 30th birthday. During this time it has been our honour to act as trustee to well over 100 pension plans taking them on journeys through the highs and lows of the pensions industry’s recent past.
We have been appointed to work with plans that have wound up with significant deficits, plans that have wound up with significant surpluses, we’ve been appointed to act on plans by both the Occupational Pensions Regulatory Authority and its successor the Pensions Regulator, we’ve helped plans get compliant with law and regulation, have helped trustees and sponsors through the dot.com boom (and bust), the 2008 financial crisis and the ever-increasingly sophisticated investment and liability management techniques that have become available.
There have been some industry firsts, notably we took the lead on the first UK plan to enter into a longevity swap and, more recently, to adopt a cash driven investment strategy. Philip Sutton commented: “We’ve won awards for our work. But what we are most proud of is the dedication and service excellence of the team in supporting plans, plan members and sponsors, as recognised by our clients. Here’s to the next 30 years!”
Weetabix Group Pension Scheme. Through our professional trusteeship business we chair the trustee board. After 18 months of negotiation with the sponsoring employer, the trustees have implemented a cash driven investment strategy and achieved certainty as to the funding level for the next 20 years – an industry first. The Scheme was awarded the Best Investment Strategy Award and Defined Benefit Plan of the Year (asset value up to £500million) at the Pensions Age 2016 Awards.